By VABayNews Staff
Arlington County, VA — A speech by Jose Quiroz, Arlington County’s sheriff and the first Latino to hold the post, has thrust Northern Virginia back into the national fight over immigration enforcement, federal authority, and the limits of local non-cooperation.
Quiroz, a Marine Corps veteran and first-generation American of Honduran descent, spoke on January 11 at a vigil in Courthouse Plaza organized by activist group We of Action. The event followed the January 7 killing of Renee Nicole Good, a U.S. citizen and mother of three, who was shot by an ICE agent during a traffic stop in Minneapolis.
Video from the vigil quickly went viral after Quiroz criticized U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, calling some ICE actions “rogue and illegal” and stating he would not assist federal agents in detaining individuals without a judicial warrant. Online, his remarks were widely framed as a demand for ICE to “leave” Arlington — a characterization that has fueled intense backlash.
What Quiroz Actually Said — and What He Didn’t
Quiroz did not issue any formal order expelling federal agents from the county. Nor does the sheriff’s office have authority over federal operations or local policing, which is handled by the Arlington County Police Department. His comments focused on due process and Arlington’s existing policy of declining voluntary ICE detainers unless backed by a judge’s warrant.
That policy predates Quiroz. In 2022, under former Sheriff Beth Arthur, Arlington ended the practice of holding individuals solely on ICE requests without judicial approval — a position common in many blue-leaning jurisdictions.
At the vigil, 34 pairs of shoes were displayed to represent victims of ICE-related incidents over the past year, many from Hispanic, Asian, and Middle Eastern communities. Clergy and local officials echoed concerns that aggressive immigration enforcement undermines trust between immigrant communities and law enforcement.
Legal Ground vs. Political Reality
From a legal standpoint, Quiroz is on relatively solid footing. Supreme Court precedent bars the federal government from compelling local officials to enforce federal law. ICE detainers are requests, not mandates, unless accompanied by a warrant.
Arlington Commonwealth’s Attorney Parisa Dehghani-Tafti reinforced that point at the vigil, stating ICE lacks authority to force entry without proper warrants or exigent circumstances. She described the Good shooting as an “execution,” language that further inflamed critics.
But politics is another matter.
On X, conservative commentators accused Quiroz of obstructing federal law enforcement and labeled him “unfit to serve.” Some called for ICE to “flood” Arlington with agents in response — a reminder that federal authorities can increase independent operations regardless of local cooperation policies.
A Flashpoint for Virginia’s Immigration Divide
Arlington is a deep-blue, affluent county with a large foreign-born population. Resistance to ICE cooperation plays well locally, but it places Virginia squarely in the broader national tug-of-war over sanctuary policies, public safety, and federal supremacy.
Supporters argue non-cooperation protects civil liberties and encourages crime reporting. Critics counter that it signals open defiance of federal law and risks turning counties into safe havens — whether or not crime data supports that claim.
What’s clear is that Quiroz’s remarks have transformed a vigil into a political flashpoint. As immigration enforcement intensifies nationwide and viral moments shape perception faster than policy, Arlington’s sheriff has become a symbol — to supporters of constitutional restraint, and to critics who see local officials crossing a dangerous line.
For now, ICE remains free to operate in Arlington. But the backlash underscores a reality center-right voters continue to raise: when local officials publicly challenge federal enforcement, they don’t reduce conflict — they escalate it.
Support Independent Journalism
Virginia Bay News is part of the Bay News Media Network — a growing group of independent, reader-supported newsrooms covering government accountability, courts, public safety, and institutional failures across the country.
Support independent journalism that isn’t funded by political parties, corporations, or government agencies
Submit tips or documents securely — if you see something wrong, we want to know
Independent reporting only works when readers stay engaged. Your attention, tips, and support help keep these stories alive.
Virginia Bay News 
Leave a comment