Courts & Justice

Virginia Bill Would Open New Path for Lawsuits Against Police, Reignite Qualified Immunity Debate

A new bill in the Virginia General Assembly, House Bill 1314, proposes allowing individuals to sue law enforcement officers for civil rights violations, potentially weakening qualified immunity. Supporters argue it ensures accountability, while critics warn it may lead to police departures and hinder public safety. The bill’s implications are profound for policing in Virginia.

Virginia Lawmakers Quietly Re-Seal Judicial Misconduct Records After Brief Transparency Window

Virginia lawmakers have re-enacted restrictions on judicial discipline records, reversing a 2023 reform that improved transparency about judges’ misconduct. The 2025 legislation limits public access to information about disciplined judges, raising concerns about accountability and trust in the judicial system, as Virginia becomes increasingly opaque compared to other states.

Tennessee’s County-Level Gun Relinquishment Fix Highlights a Larger Due Process Debate

Tennessee is adopting a procedural change requiring detailed documentation for transferring firearms from individuals with domestic violence convictions to third parties. Supporters argue it closes loopholes, enhancing victim safety, while critics warn it risks eroding due process and privacy. The grassroots movement raises complex questions about enforcement and potential overreach.

Joint Custody, Criminal Charges, and a System Under Strain

The Suffolk parental abduction case underscores the complexities arising from vague custody orders, which can lead to conflicts and enforcement issues. Breone’a Haskett Lee faced charges after taking her daughters to Texas without permission. This highlights the need for precise custody terms to prevent escalations that turn civil disputes into criminal matters.

Fairfax County’s Immigration Policies Under Scrutiny After Deadly Release

A deadly Reston shooting has placed Fairfax County’s justice and immigration policies under intense scrutiny after an illegal immigrant with a lengthy local criminal record was released from custody—despite an ICE detainer—only to be charged with homicide the next day. Federal officials say the tragedy was preventable, while county leaders defend their decisions as lawful…

Weaponizing Allegations: Why Governor Youngkin Must Address False Domestic Violence Claims in Family Court

The article by Michael Phillips highlights the serious issue of false domestic violence allegations in Virginia’s family court, impacting many parents, particularly fathers. It discusses how these allegations are often used as manipulation tactics during custody battles, with dire consequences for the accused. The author calls for legal reforms to hold false accusers accountable.

Kemler the Quitter: When Judges Walk Away From the Damage They’ve Done

Judge Lisa B. Kemler’s upcoming retirement in 2025 is viewed by some in Virginia’s legal community as graceful, but many families feel abandoned by her decisions. Her tenure contributed to a failing system, leaving victims unprotected and families fractured. Her exit symbolizes a troubling trend of judges avoiding accountability, prioritizing profit over justice.

Broken Bench Series 1: The Silent Crisis of Judicial Appointments

Virginia citizens have lost the right to elect judges, transforming judicial selection into a secretive system dominated by political insiders. This undermines accountability and democratic representation, with significant implications for civil rights and community health. A movement is growing to restore popular elections and empower citizens in judicial processes.

The Revolving Door of Injustice: How The McCammon Group and Juridical Solutions Profit Off the Broken System They Helped Create

In a world where family court and civil litigation have become synonymous with prolonged suffering and endless bills, a growing sector quietly rakes in profits by exploiting the very chaos it claims to cure: Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR). Two major players dominate Virginia’s private ADR scene: The McCammon Group and Juridical Solutions PLC. On the…

The Quiet Exodus: Why Virginia Judges Like Lisa B. Kemler Are Retiring Early

In 2025, Virginia experiences a wave of early judicial retirements led by Judge Lisa B. Kemler, raising concerns about the judiciary’s future. Factors include better pay in private dispute resolution, declining public trust, overwhelming backlog pressures, fear of accountability, and pension incentives. This trend highlights a broken judicial system needing reform.